Guild icon
Tulpa.info
Tulpa Discussion / tulpa-questions-2
Overflow channel for #tulpa-questions Forum Link to Tulpa Questions: https://community.tulpa.info/forum/13-tulpa-questions-answers/
Avatar
Thank you for answering my question!
Avatar
Avatar
Kit
so it's just how much practice she has (oopsies)
Deleted User 4/18/2021 6:45 PM
the be fair i wouldn't put the blame on your host it's your brain as well and what you put your effort in practicing will help your host too
Avatar
that makes sense thanks dude
Avatar
My visualization skill was already decent, maybe 35-40% and it took two years of daily practice to get to 80% ish. Hypnagogic assisted visualization is like 100%+ indistinguishable from real life.
11:33 PM
But it's not easy to lock in.
Avatar
Hi can a tulpa be created by accident like I think in some fkrm then interact whit it for 2 days ia enough to make a tulpa?
Avatar
The way I see it a tulpa is two things: Autonomy and complexity. The autonomy part can be made instantly or take a long time to get right, depending on how suggestible you are and what your mindset is. Complexity can be achieved with strong personality forcing early on or over time with exposure to the world. Complexity though is a funny beast. It sort of works in the same way, but your mind will fill in the blanks often in a very stupid way if they start attaching themselves to negative thoughts you're having. A tulpa should be questioning what it's making part of its identity if it's doing things the long-way, rather than just accepting any stray thoughts as theirs. Or the result is that they just attach to whatever random nonsensical stuff the brain is generating all the time - which can often be really unhealthy and self-deprecating to internalize.
Avatar
Lula! | 👻 4/25/2021 4:27 PM
Definitely agree they should be questioning what they make part of their identity!!
4:27 PM
Tulpas should reflect and be introspective like anyone should be!
Avatar
Avatar
Braig
Hi can a tulpa be created by accident like I think in some fkrm then interact whit it for 2 days ia enough to make a tulpa?
It could be enough to make a tulpa but if the tulpa seems to appear without any effort/conscious desire on your part you might have DID or OSDD
3:44 AM
I'm not an expert here tho
Avatar
Lily | 👻 BOT 4/27/2021 3:48 AM
I generally would not entertain that without talking to a professional. I certainly wouldn't take headmates appearing without effort to be the only factor prior to assuming that, not without some other sort of dissociative issues present.
Avatar
Yes ofc you should talk to a professional if you suspect that
3:53 AM
Yeah sorry if I worded that wrong I don't think I'm capable of diagnosing anyone I've just heard that that might be one of the signs and it's something to maybe research just to be safe
Avatar
I made multiple tulpas without any intention of making tulpas nor did I know anything about tulpas in general. I do not have DID or OSDD
3:59 AM
There are many cases of completely accidental tulpas and it is certainly not a sign of DID or OSDD on its own.
4:00 AM
Paired with other symptoms you’d have a case, but by itself it means basically nothing
Avatar
KiTkAt( •̀ .̫ •́ )✧ 🌺 [Kaleido] BOT 4/27/2021 8:47 AM
Yes ofc you should talk to a professional if you suspect that
@Tinyparrot - jump no, research is the last thing you want to do, especially if you have accidental tulpas. you can by accident force your system into believing it has did/osdd. medical students experience this, why would an uneducated person have a higher chance of avoiding it? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_students%27_disease just talk to a professional if there are any concerns and don't do any research on your own
💯 2
Avatar
Again, I'm not trying to diagnose anyone, but I've personally done a lot of research into DID and OSDD and even looked through the criteria to make sure I didn't have it, is it really such a bad thing to educate yourself? (edited)
Avatar
we've seen multiple times in did community singlets joining just to do research and changing their name to "system" after a few days in fact we haven't seen a singlet that stayed a singlet for longer than a week in did community it shows how suggestive and vulnerable people can develop pseudo-did symptoms especially if they do know criteria it gets so bad that once we met a person who was saying "did/osdd is not that uncommon! i helped 25% of people on my gaming discord realise they have did"
12:37 PM
i know you mean well but there is a danger in suggesting that someone can have a strong disorder and tell them to do research if you say it to vulnerable and suggestible person that research will work on them like personality forcing
Avatar
But I feel like compared to other disorders the criteria there are harder to meet right?
Avatar
did you read that wiki about medical student's disease?
Avatar
Generally speaking, more knowledge is usually an advantage. However, in this specific sort of situation, there's a real risk of misdiagnosing oneself. Medical students' disease is a serious threat and is not to be taken lightly.
Avatar
the only benefit from knowing if you have did is if it means you will get treatment if you want to know if you have did you might as well go to a professional and explore it with them
👆 1
Avatar
Yes, I read it
Avatar
i know you mean well but the only way you can help is to suggest seeing a professional
12:39 PM
even professionals are very cautious with putting a label of did on a person because of how strong it is
Avatar
Yes I do agree but I don't think everyone with an accidental tulpa should see a professional
Avatar
and yet you told them they might have did osdd
12:39 PM
why would that matter?
12:39 PM
if not to see a professional
Avatar
Ok so let me just explain myself a bit better
Avatar
doctors don't even bring did up to their patients for months
12:40 PM
i know where you are coming from but there is more harm than good in it
12:40 PM
people do develop pseudo-did when they are suggested to research did
12:40 PM
and you might potentially be harming people
12:40 PM
do you want that?
Avatar
Do they really?
Avatar
yes
Avatar
How common is that thought?
Avatar
are you reading what i say...
Avatar
Yes?
12:41 PM
i think you skipped most of what i said
Avatar
That's just your own experience, I'd like to see if there's actual documentation on this, maybe the 25% DID thing was a coincidence or someone being intentionally manipulative
Avatar
of course it is people i met
12:42 PM
are you ready to live with awareness you are doing something potentially hazardous for someone's mental health?
12:42 PM
then ok you can excuse yourself more
Avatar
But I feel like that's kind of like saying that having gay friends can turn someone gay and gay people hanging out together is proof
Avatar
are you a professional?
Avatar
Are you?
Avatar
do you have medical training
12:42 PM
no i'm not
Avatar
No?
Avatar
but i am aware i should not be giving anything close to medical advice
12:43 PM
"Medical students' disease (also known as second year syndrome or intern's syndrome) is a condition frequently reported in medical students, who perceive themselves to be experiencing the symptoms of a disease that they are studying."
Avatar
Did you read the part where I said I'm not trying to diagnose anyone
Avatar
but you are suggesting to do research
12:43 PM
while medical students who know what they are doing are experiencing symptoms of a disorder they are studying
Avatar
Yes I think everyone should do research on DID and OSDD and any mental illness really
Avatar
how much better a person with no training can be immune to that?
12:44 PM
no!!
12:44 PM
Medical students' disease (also known as second year syndrome or intern's syndrome) is a condition frequently reported in medical students, who perceive themselves to be experiencing the symptoms of a disease that they are studying.
Avatar
I've never experienced medical student disorder in all my research into mental health
Avatar
you are causing harm to people!!
12:44 PM
you should not be saying that!!
12:44 PM
the only way to research serious mental health disorders is with mental health professional
Avatar
Have you really never done any research into psychology?
Avatar
yes! enough to know that Medical students' disease (also known as second year syndrome or intern's syndrome) is a condition frequently reported in medical students, who perceive themselves to be experiencing the symptoms of a disease that they are studying.
Avatar
So that's everything you know about psychology?
Avatar
i'm surprised you didn't learn about this with your research
Avatar
I did???
Avatar
no, i know much more, but go around and tell people they might have a disorder
12:45 PM
and tell them to do more research
12:45 PM
which might lead to experience medical student's disease
Avatar
I do know this exists, I have had my own "episodes" of medical student disorder ex. one time I thought I might have bipolar disorder for two days then realized I probably didn't
Avatar
you are being irresponsible if you can't aknowledge the fact that it is potentially dangerous
Avatar
@Tinyparrot Robin, do you think that because you didn't experience medical student disorder that means others won't?
Avatar
well i'm glad you realised after two days! but not everyone does
Avatar
Have either of you ever experienced it?
👍 1
Avatar
yes, but we were doing therapy, so we brought it up with our therapist
12:46 PM
and consulted it with her
Avatar
That's good, I'm glad you did
Avatar
but if you tell people to do their own research, they don't have opportunity like that
Avatar
I think if someone does have a problem with that it's a good thing to bring up with a therapist
Avatar
well of course!
Avatar
If someone thinks they have DID/OSDD and they consult a therapist, then they'll either learn that they have it or learn that they have medical student disorder
Avatar
you are asking how often that happens but how can you accept any % of risk that someone might misdiagnose themselves with did
Avatar
Either way, going to a therapist will address the problem
12:48 PM
But if someone doesn't think they have DID/OSDD after looking at the symptoms, they don't have to see a therapist
Avatar
Avatar
Tinyparrot
If someone thinks they have DID/OSDD and they consult a therapist, then they'll either learn that they have it or learn that they have medical student disorder
from what we've seen in did community singlets that researched did and started experiencing pseudo-did are not seeking help they are just being dragged into experiencing some of the symptoms more
Avatar
And I think that's bad and they should seek help
Avatar
the problem is if the research involves getting into did community which is very unhealthy
12:49 PM
well i'm glad we agree on this
12:53 PM
please look at it this way: there are different types of plural systems there are gateway systems tulpa systems soulbond systems and others when someone starts developing plural symptoms by themselves the first thing they read about will define the believes about how their system works if they read a guide to soulbound as their first one and they resonate a bit that's basically system forcing which will guide them towards believing their headmates are real entities from other dimension or real ghosts similarly if someone mentions did to them they might resonate with it a bit and with time the did guides will be system forcing guides like it works for gateway systems tulpa systems and soulbound systems it will have expectations of how things work and it will make you experience it (edited)
12:53 PM
please remember about osdd-2 which is basically did but resulted from brainwashing
12:54 PM
everyone experiences dissociation to some extend and it can become much more severe to a did-level and it's even described in dsm-5 under osdd-2
12:54 PM
for someone suggestible reading and doing research can be equivalent of self-brainwashing
👆 1
Exported 100 message(s)
Timezone: UTC+0
Page 1 ... Page 6 ... Page 7 ... Page 8 ... Page 124